Tensions Flare in Peshawar High Court as Chief Justice Exits Amid CM’s Attempt to Speak
PESHAWAR – In a rare and dramatic display of judicial boundary-setting, Peshawar High Court (PHC) Chief Justice Ishtiaq Ibrahim walked out of an open courtroom on Monday after Khyber Pakhtunkhwa Chief Minister Ali Amin Gandapur attempted to address the bench during an ongoing session.
The incident, which has quickly become a flashpoint for discussions on judicial decorum and the separation of powers, occurred while the court was busy with its daily cause list. The sudden interruption by the province’s highest elected official led to a brief but palpable tension that resonated through the packed courtroom.
A Sudden Interruption
The atmosphere in the PHC was typical of a busy Monday morning until Chief Minister Gandapur entered the room. As the Chief Minister rose and prepared to speak directly to the bench, Chief Justice Ibrahim acted swiftly. Rather than engaging in a dialogue or allowing the CM to proceed, the Chief Justice maintained a strict adherence to legal protocol.
Observing that the court was in session and that formal procedures must be respected, the Chief Justice opted to rise from his seat and exit the courtroom, effectively adjourning the immediate proceedings.
The Weight of Protocol
To those unfamiliar with the inner workings of the legal system, the exit might seem abrupt. However, for the legal community, it was a symbolic gesture of the court’s independence. In a court of law, communication typically happens through legal counsel and formal petitions, rather than direct addresses from political figures, regardless of their rank.
“The courtroom is a space where the law is the only supreme authority,” noted one legal observer present during the incident. “When a political leader attempts to speak outside of the established legal framework, it puts the judiciary in a difficult position. The Chief Justice’s exit was a silent but firm reminder that the bench does not operate on political schedules.”
The Aftermath
Following the Chief Justice’s departure, the Chief Minister remained in the courtroom for a short period before eventually leaving. While the specific details of what Mr. Gandapur intended to discuss were not formally recorded in the session, the event has sparked a wider conversation about the relationship between the provincial government and the judiciary in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa.
Supporters of the Chief Minister suggest he may have been seeking to bring urgent public matters to the court’s attention. Conversely, legal experts argue that maintaining the sanctity of the courtroom is essential to ensuring that justice is seen to be done without the appearance of political influence.
Why It Matters
This encounter is more than just a procedural hiccup; it reflects the ongoing delicate balance between Pakistan’s executive and judicial branches. At a time when the public looks to both institutions for stability, such moments of friction highlight the challenges of governance and the rigid, yet necessary, boundaries of the law.
As of Monday afternoon, the Peshawar High Court has resumed its normal functions. However, the image of the Chief Justice walking out remains a poignant reminder that in the eyes of the court, the robe and the gavel follow a script that even a Chief Minister cannot rewrite on the fly.
- Sponsored: Looking for thebest CCTV camera price in Pakistan? Shop IP cameras,Wireless cameras, Long range 4G Solar security cameras Indoor Outdoor Bulb camera4G Camera and Multi Lans cameras and other electronics for home and business at unbeatable prices. MyGSS.pk offers a wide selection of quality brands like VStarcam,IMOU,Dahua,Ezviz,Tenda,V380,Hikvision,andTP-Link and also the official distributor of VStarcam brand.” COD is available in Lahore, Karachi, Islamabad, Rawalpindi, Pashiwer, Multan, Quetta, & over 300+ cities and towns in Pakistan, And offers CCTV camera Installation guide on website